首页
财务会计
医药卫生
金融经济
考公考编
外语考试
学历提升
职称考试
建筑工程
IT考试
其他
登录
职称考试
Shaming Punishments Last month, James Connolly, a junior at the University ...
Shaming Punishments Last month, James Connolly, a junior at the University ...
admin
2020-12-24
68
问题
Shaming Punishments
Last month, James Connolly, a junior at the University of Massachusetts, stood in front of a local police station wearing a toga (长袍) as punishment.
His crime? He was charged with underage drinking, illegal possession of alcohol and excessive noise while holding a party.
This shaming punishment has increased in the U.S. in recent years, mostly imposed by local judges for less-serious crimes, such as drunk driving and theft.
They believe shame is the best petty crime deterrent (威慑). For example, in Tennessee, Judge James McKenzie has made shoplifters (商店货物扒手) stand outside Wal-Mart with signs that read, "I am a thief put here by order of Judge McKenzie".
"Alternative punishments like community service and fines don' t convey moral condemnation (谴责) of the criminal" said Dan Kahan , a University of Chicago Law School professor, in an article published on the university's website. "They aren't shameful enough."
Shaming punishments are sometimes called Scarlet (红色的) Letter punishments. The name comes from U.S. author Nathaniel Hawthorne's 1850 novel The Scarlet Letter. In this novel, a woman is forced to wear a scarlet "A" on her clothes as punishment for her adultery (通奸).
However, University of Iowa law professor Andrew Hosmanek said there is an important difference between the shaming punishments of colonial America and those assigned in states hke Tennessee.
"Early societies often had a re-acceptance ceremony to welcome the offender back into main society," says Hosmanek. "Contemporary punishments in America lack this."
Supporters of shaming punishment argue that public shaming is a good way of expressing community values. Some judges say shamed offenders seldom repeat their crimes.
Others aren't so' sure. "There is little evidence to suggest that shaming punishments are successful in preventing people from committing specific crimes. And a shamed criminal may face a hard battle to regain credibility in society," said Hosmanek. "So, a shaming punishment may force the offender into more crimes to support himself."
Experts also debate shaming punishment's damage to human dignity. "Since the point is to shame, it's of course degrading (侮辱人格的) , " said Linda Malone, director of the Human Rights and National Security Law Programme at William and Mary Law School.
"U.S. law only prohibits punishment that is ' cruel and unusual' not ' inhuman and degrading' . It' s very difficult for a thief to prove that holding a sign in front of Wal-Mart is ' cruel and unusual '."
Which of the following punishments does NOT morally condemn a criminal?()
选项
A.Holding a sign that announces his or her crime.
B.Publishing his or her name on a website.
C.Apologizing for the crime in front of Wal-Mart.
D.Having to do useful work to help others without being paid.
答案
D
解析
解析 :第五段 : "Alternative punishments like (D) community service and fines don't convey moral condemnation (谴责) of the criminal" said Dan Kahan , a University of Chicago Law School professor, in an article published On the university's website. "They aren't shameful enough."
转载请注明原文地址:https://ti.zuoweng.com/ti/jSpQKKKQ
相关试题推荐
LifeatAiehiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl.I...
LifeatAiehiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl.I...
LifeatAiehiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl.I...
LifeatAichiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl....
LifeatAichiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl....
LifeatAichiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl....
LifeatAichiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl....
LifeatAichiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl....
LifeatAichiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl....
LifeatAichiUniversity I'mYamamotoMika,a22-year-oldJapanesegirl....
随机试题
( )是指直接或间接影响和作用于培训活动的诸要素的总和。 A、培训环境 B
属于商业固体废物的是( )。 A.丢弃的主、副食品 B.废砖瓦
下列哪种情况是类风湿关节炎的典型体征 A.肩关节活动受限 B.扳机指 C.
胎儿的血液循环特点有 A.体内有纯粹的动脉血 B.卵圆孔沟通肺动脉与主动脉弓
采用热压灭菌法用什么蒸气灭菌效果最好 A、湿饱和蒸气 B、水蒸气 C、
由同种药物的分子相互结合成大分子的反应称为
某项目拟采用升流式厌氧污泥床反应器(UASB)处理生产废水,消化气(沼气)应由(
中药功效是指A.中药的作用趋向B.中药的作用部位C.中药的安全程度D.中药防治诊断疾病及保健作用E.中药作用性质
在王某被杀一案中,侦查人员取得了下列线索:(1)王某的朋友李某的陈述,证明王某患有严重的失眠症;(2)王某邻居张某的陈述,描述案发当天曾看见一个衣着邋遢...
如果纳税义务人自缴款期限届满之日起()内仍未缴税款,经海关关长批准,海关可以采取强制措施。A.15日B.3个月C.6个月D.30日